Lla Dafern/Archive 16
From IBWiki
|
|
|
| Archive 2005: February – July
| August – September
| October
| November
| December
|
Contents |
Dornburg Disaster
... on which I would like pertinent comments and suggestions for improvement. I intend to publish at least one illustration in the near future. Kyrmse 05:43, 3 January 2008 (PST)
Blank Maps, Easily Edited
... are here: http://english.freemap.jp/index.html
Kyrmse 04:44, 9 January 2008 (PST)
Population and Area of European Nations
This:
http://www.geocities.com/xliponia/IB-EU.PNG
is a quick spreadsheet I made containing population & area data for the nations of Europe. My remark is that precious little quantitative information of this sort is available, not only about Europe, but elsewhere as well. You can't even calculate population density for many of the countries. Besides, what is this thing called km2? One of those funny Louisiannian units, it seems. Shouldn't we do something about this?
Kyrmse 09:39, 20 February 2008 (PST)
- Just because our units are rationally designed and not arbitrary with bushels, pecks, ounces, pfennings and what have you!
- To get the data for Louisianne, I roughed it in, extrapolating from the US states *here* that Louisianne supercedes *there*. I suppose you could do similarly with the provinces and such that Xliponia covers *here*
- And FWIW, my understanding about miles *there* is that *there* they're about 2.1 km or something strange? BoArthur 11:21, 20 February 2008 (PST)
- 1.48, so not that weird; here they're about 1.6km. The incompleteness of this is astounding, although there is usually a good reason for everything. I believe the RTC is a nation whilst the FK is a supernational organisation. Surely the SR is the biggest nation in the world (35 million pop.), with all its worldwide territories? Or the NAL which has Canada and the eastern half of the USA from *here*? --Quentin 09:41, 21 February 2008 (PST)
- The largest country might still be Russia as *here*--Marc Pasquin 12:05, 21 February 2008 (PST)
- I'd think Russia would still trump the SR, since most of its global territories are quite small. For Luxemburg's area, I was going to add the area of the Grand Duchy *here* to the area of Belgium's Luxembourg Province *here*. Benkarnell 12:24, 21 February 2008 (PST)
- The FK is kind of both a supranational organisation and also a, well, "federated" state. I guess quantitative data has been a long time in coming to IB. I did the population and area of Ter Mair quite a long time ago, but up til then, such information has been scarce indeed! Kudos to the bold adventurers into the unknowns maws and quagmires of IB censustaking! Elemtilas 14:56, 21 February 2008 (PST)
- I remember reading that in IB they look at each entity uniquely and quibble less over defining sub/supra/nationality. I would be curious what entities are members of the League of Nations. Is Kemr? Or just the FK? Is the SR a member? Is Ter Mair? Novgorod? The Lusoamerican Union? Benkarnell 15:22, 21 February 2008 (PST)
- Well, in the League of Nations charter, it says "peaceful community of nations", so I suspect that entities like Ter Mair (provinces) are not members. I don't have a list of member states (but I have the feeling it is quite comprehensive), but am sure that individual countries have the right to apply for membership. Supranational organisations like the Commonwealth or Scandinavian Realm can also join, I'm sure. Since the LoN works primarily through the mechanism of "regional assemblies", an entity like the SR naturally forms its own "regional assembly". That said, it seems that ministers can be sent by a wide variety of nations, regional interest blocs, trade organistaions and the like in order to address the various regional assemblies, and even the Council of the World itself.
- The LoN is, as far as we know, a very powerful organisation. Very much unlike our UN. It also seems to be a much more behind the scenes kind of organisation. Elemtilas 19:00, 21 February 2008 (PST)
Agreed that supranational organisations, federated states, states and subnational entities are pretty much like a scale in IB. So, what would maps look like *there*? I suppose it really depends on the mapmaker. One would treat the HRE, the RTC, the SR and the FK like states and their components like subnational entities, others would treat them more like supranational organisations. My preferred solution would probably be something with shades of colours: England, Kemr and Scotland in different shades of, say, green, Veneda and Lithuania in different shades of, say, red.
As for data regarding area and population: in the case of the RTC I think I omitted area, since most RTC provinces do not entirely coincide with existing provinces and the country encompasses territories of four different countries. As for the population, I extrapolated the numbers of each province from the existing provinces as starting points, made some educates guesses regarding the rest, and made some changes for a different course of history (for example, the fact that there was no massive genocide in WW2). In the case of the Vozgian republic, I based both area and population on the data for the corresponding Russian rayons. In some cases where the borders did not match, I had to make some educated guesses again, but I'm pretty sure the current data (153,200 km2, 1,404,500 inhabitants) are pretty close to the truth, albeit maybe not for the full 100%.
As for the League of Nations, there's one thing I remember pretty well from what its conceiver, Dr. Cowan, wrote about it: that it is not an organisation like the UN *here*, with member states and ambassadors and the like. It's more some kind of recurring international conference, which starts acting once a state behaves badly in its relations with other states.
Cheers, —IJzeren Jan Uszkiełtu? 05:03, 22 February 2008 (PST)
- Right. Members have "ministers" (usually more than one) that sit on the various conferences. And I don't think the UN has ambassadors from multinational organistations, either.
- And even the NAL is listed as a supranational organization on FOIB, Marc's sites, etc. Methinks the humble term "province" is just one more "Less is More" situation. Benkarnell 06:01, 22 February 2008 (PST)
- The NAL really isn't a supranational organisation. Not as I understand the term, anyway! I can understand where any confusion comes from, because it is both independent and dependent upon the monarchs of four foreign nations for heads of state. It is both a federal national government and something of an equal party to one of its constituent members (keeping in mind that the early SLC sought its early legitimacy within the arena of the Native confederacies). And some of its provinces have special relationships with foreign monarchs. The UT often (and rightfully so) acts as an independent country. What I mean to say is that the provinces are not much more independent countries than the states are *here*. But the provinces aren't independent countries any more than our states.
- So, while I concur that the provinces have a "more" situation when compared to states or provinces *here*, I don't see how that makes the NAL itself a supranational organisation. Elemtilas 15:14, 23 February 2008 (PST)
Back on the topic of population, I think the figures have some bloopers in them - The FK's population is 57 million, Kemr's is 7 million and England's is 5 million. That would suggest that Scotland's is 45 million! Surely, wrong. The population of Britain *here* is 59 million, which would be comparable with *there*, but I'm understanding the population of IB is slightly less than here? --Quentin 13:37, 28 February 2008 (PST)
- But is the population of IB slightly smaller than *here*? I have never seen this stated explicitly. And if so, why? (That is the reason why I started this thread in the first place) Kyrmse 04:32, 29 February 2008 (PST)
- Some places are more crowded (Henua, for one). Some places are less crowded (Francophone Luxemburg, for one; probably the Unincorporated Territories for another). I know that places like Asia and Latin America are more developed, and that may correlate with lower birth rates and a lower population. I can't think of any reason why Europe or North America would have fewer people. Benkarnell 06:30, 29 February 2008 (PST)
- I expect São Paulo (not my hometown *here*, but where I live *here*) to be less populous in IB, since IOTL we have 19 million in the metropolitan region... I imagine that the capital of the Republic of Paraná is a more civilised place to live in - that the Republic is less crowded along the coast and more evenly populated in the interior. Kyrmse 04:26, 3 March 2008 (PST)
For Airship Lovers
Try the Xeppelin font (www.iconian.com/fonts/xep.zip) from this page. Kyrmse 08:50, 26 February 2008 (PST)
How to Tell if You're a True IB Citizen
When arriving at work one of the first favourites you open on your computer has the URL: http://ib.frath.net/w/Special:Recentchanges Kyrmse 09:59, 5 March 2008 (PST)
- Most every workday, before the kids show up. Benkarnell 07:14, 22 March 2008 (PDT)
More mathoms: Hay-on-Wye
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/conculture/message/11006
http://www.geocities.com/flagsofillbethisad/hw.html
This seems to be in keeping with giving micronations *here* status as independent nations *there* (Saugeais, Conch Republic), albeit with very different histories. Assuming this is QSS (and it seems to be), what is it exactly? How came it to have an English name when it appears to be in the middle of Ill Paes? Or is this one of those things which we can allow to remain mysterious until somebody wants to devote more attention to it? Benkarnell 07:14, 22 March 2008 (PDT)
- Probably a bunch of saxons who never got around the idea of living in a chomro country.--Marc Pasquin 11:41, 22 March 2008 (PDT)
- ahem* Conch Republic's not actually autonomous. It started out that way, but it looks like Irish Occupied Florida's going to turn out more germanized than East Florida; that is, if we can ever get anything out of Jan van Steenbergen on the subject. It's like he's moved halfway across a continent or something... :) BoArthur 20:27, 28 April 2008 (UTC)
A Flag to Hoist? A Pin to Wear?
... what would they look like if we want to show we belong to Ill Bethisad, or that Ill Bethisad belongs to us? I can imagine my car flying a small Xliponian flag on the antenna, but on the other side? An airship with a red dragon? Come on! ;-) Suggestions welcome. Kyrmse 06:54, 9 April 2008 (PDT)
- I've actually printed a slightly different version of Image:HE-oval.PNG as a real sticker, but I keep it on a notebook rather than on my car. It would be hard explaining Rongorongo to the curious... I know that in the US such oval stickers have no legal status, and many people display stickers representing their favorite beach town or university. I don't know if an "XL" (or even an "IB") sticker would be OK down in Paraná. Benkarnell 07:12, 9 April 2008 (PDT)
- That's part of why I created my online webstore, and Marc his... :) I'm seriously thinking about buying the Repubulique Française shirt. BoArthur 07:39, 9 April 2008 (PDT)
- You can wear an IB cap, I still have some. otherwise, I could send you a vectorial version of the Cambrian flag you could print on sticker paper.--Marc Pasquin 11:31, 9 April 2008 (PDT)
Technical note.
Please don't use the pipe symbol ("|") when linking to another website or it breaks the link. Thanks. --Quentin 02:10, 16 April 2008 (PDT)
- I've added a note regarding this in the Help files (I don't know if anybody ever uses them, but you never know...). —IJzeren Jan Uszkiełtu? 14:17, 17 April 2008 (PDT)
Oblong Office
A discrepancy has been noted in the location of the GM's office: either in the capitol or in the Octagon House. I am sure that the reference to the Octagon House is righter; but have also suggested that a harmonisation could be made whereby the GM has his principle office in the Octagon House and an "office of convenience" in the capitol for when he's there. Elemtilas 21:57, 27 April 2008 (UTC)

